Malta vs Sicily

Malta vs Sicily


Malta Short Let: Cozy Stay in Gzira
Sliema Area
Modern Designer Finished
2 Bedrooms + Games Room.
First floor with Maltese Balcony
Large back Terrace with swinging sofa
Fully Airconditioned + Full Kitchen
3 TVs, including 65” with backlight.
Apartment Image
Book Now:
Google Travel | Direct (Cheapest) | Booking.com | Airbnb

Best island for a little break. Summary >

  • Malta and Sicily both offer rich history, stunning beaches, and vibrant culture, but Malta is slightly better for short trips due to its compact size.
  • Malta is more budget-friendly and easier to navigate without a car, while Sicily offers more diverse landscapes and cuisine.
  • English is widely spoken in Malta, making it more accessible for international travelers, unlike Sicily where Italian predominates.
  • Malta boasts some of the oldest free-standing structures in the world, like the Ġgantija Temples, predating Stonehenge and the Egyptian pyramids.

Why Choose Malta?

Malta, a small archipelago in the central Mediterranean, is perfect for a quick getaway. Its compact size (316 km²) lets you explore the Beaches, Valletta, Mdina, and Gozo in just a week. English is an official language, easing communication, and it’s affordable, with daily costs from €58-170 per person. Divers will love spots like Paradise Bay and the Blue Lagoon.

Why Consider Sicily?

Sicily, the Mediterranean’s largest island (25,711 km²), suits longer trips of 10-15 days. It offers Mount Etna, Greek temples, and sandy beaches like San Vito Lo Capo. Sicilian cuisine—think arancini and cannoli—is world-famous, and its diverse terrain appeals to hikers and nature lovers.

For its ease of travel, unique ancient sites, and manageable size, Malta edges out as the top pick for 2025, especially if you’re after a hassle-free, memorable escape.

Malta vs Sicily, A Mediterranean Showdown

Choosing between Malta and Sicily for your 2025 Mediterranean adventure? Both islands dazzle with history, beaches, and culture, but they cater to different vibes. Malta’s compact charm, breaks it down for fast readers. Expect location insights, top attractions, culture, nature, food, practical tips, tables, and a FAQ—all tailored to help you decide!

Location and Reachability

Malta sits south of Sicily in the central Mediterranean, a small archipelago easily reached via Malta International Airport with flights from major European hubs. Its efficient buses and ferries make exploring Malta, Gozo, and Comino simple—no car needed. Learn more about getting there at How to Get to Malta.

Sicily, off Italy’s southern tip, is the Mediterranean’s largest island. Airports in Palermo and Catania connect it globally, and ferries link it to the mainland. Its size means a car is handy for venturing beyond cities like Palermo.

AspectMaltaSicily
LocationCentral Mediterranean, south of SicilyOff southern Italy
Size316 km²25,711 km²
AirportsMalta International AirportPalermo, Catania, others
TransportBuses, ferries, car-free friendlyCar recommended, buses in cities

Attractions and Highlights

Both islands pack a punch with sights, and here are the top 10 attractions for each, showcased in tables for quick reference.

Malta’s Top 10 Attractions:

RankAttractionDescription
1VallettaUNESCO-listed capital with Baroque streets and St. John’s Co-Cathedral (Valletta Self-Guided Tour).
2MdinaMedieval “Silent City” with narrow lanes and panoramic views (Mdina’s Lesser-Known Gems).
3Gozo’s Ġgantija TemplesPrehistoric temples older than Stonehenge (Ġgantija Temples Guide).
4Blue Lagoon (Comino)Crystal-clear bay for swimming and snorkeling, a must-visit gem.
5Ħaġar Qim & Mnajdra TemplesAncient UNESCO sites showcasing Malta’s Neolithic past (Ħaġar Qim Guide).
6Paradise BaySecluded beach with clear waters, perfect for relaxation (Paradise Bay Guide).
7Fort St. AngeloHistoric fortress in Birgu with a rich Knights’ legacy (Fort St. Angelo).
8Golden BayPopular sandy beach for sunbathing and water sports (Golden Bay Guide).
9The Three CitiesHistoric trio (Birgu, Senglea, Bormla) with fortifications and charm (Three Cities History).
10Ramla BayGozo’s red-sand beach, a hidden paradise (Ramla Bay Guide).

Sicily’s Top 10 Attractions:

RankAttractionDescription
1Mount EtnaActive volcano with hiking trails and stunning volcanic landscapes.
2Valley of the TemplesUNESCO site in Agrigento with well-preserved Greek temples.
3Syracuse (Ortigia)Ancient city with Greek ruins and a charming historic island.
4TaorminaCliffside town with a Greek theater and Ionian Sea views.
5PalermoVibrant capital with Norman palaces and bustling markets.
6CefalùCoastal town with a Norman cathedral and sandy beaches.
7Aeolian IslandsVolcanic archipelago with stunning scenery and boat trips.
8Villa Romana del CasaleRoman villa with intricate mosaics, a UNESCO treasure.
9CataniaLively city at Etna’s base with Baroque architecture and fish markets.
10RagusaBaroque hilltop town with picturesque streets and historic charm.

Malta’s small size means you can see all its highlights in a week, while Sicily’s vastness often requires picking a region for a 7-10 day trip.

Cultural and Historical Significance

Malta’s history spans Phoenicians, Romans, Arabs, and the Knights of Malta, who shaped its fortified cities (The Knights of Malta). Its Megalithic Temples, like Ġgantija, are older than Stonehenge (Step into the Ancient World), with three UNESCO sites.

Sicily blends Greek, Arab, Norman, and Spanish influences, seen in its five UNESCO sites, like the Valley of the Temples and Roman mosaics.

Malta’s prehistoric edge makes it special, while Sicily offers broader ancient diversity.

Natural Beauty and Outdoor Activities

Malta’s rocky coastlines shine for diving, with spots like San Blas Beach (San Blas Beach Guide) and Golden Bay (Golden Bay Guide). Hike the Dingli Cliffs or Gozo trails.

Sicily’s varied landscapes—Mount Etna, sandy San Vito Lo Capo, and mountain reserves—suit hikers and beachgoers.

Malta’s compact nature makes daily adventures easy, giving it a slight edge.

Cuisine

Maltese food mixes Mediterranean flair with pastizzi, rabbit stew, and local wines like Girgentina (Maltese Pastizzi Recipe).

Sicilian cuisine dazzles with arancini, cannoli, and seafood, rooted in Italian mastery.

Malta’s unique flavors stand out, though Sicily’s variety is hard to beat.

AspectMaltaSicily
CuisinePastizzi, rabbit stew, ftiraArancini, cannoli, pasta alla Norma
WineSmall-batch, Girgentina, ĠellewżaDiverse, Etna wines
ExperienceCozy, intimate diningBustling, varied options

Practical Information

Language: Malta’s English fluency simplifies travel (Why Is Malta Important). Sicily relies on Italian, with English in tourist zones.

Transport: Malta’s buses and ferries suffice (Malta Travel Guide). Sicily often requires a car.

Cost: Malta’s €58-170 daily cost aligns with Sicily’s €50-220, but Malta feels more budget-friendly.

Safety: Both are safe, with some cautions in Sicilian cities (Is Malta Safe).

Malta’s ease wins for short, car-free trips.

Tourist Numbers and Crowdedness

Malta sees 2.25 million visitors yearly, Sicily 5.51 million. Malta’s smaller size can feel busier per square kilometer, but Sicily’s higher volume reflects its scale.

Comparison Table

AspectMaltaSicily
Size316 km², compact25,711 km², vast
Trip DurationGreat for 1 weekBest for 10-15 days
LanguageEnglish, MalteseItalian, Sicilian
TransportBuses, ferries, no car neededCar advised, buses in cities
HistoryPrehistoric temples, 3 UNESCO sitesGreek ruins, 5 UNESCO sites
BeachesRocky, Sandy,PebblesSandy and varied
Cost (Daily)€50-170€55-220

FAQ Section

  1. Which island suits a short trip?
    Malta, for its small size and easy exploration.
  2. Is English common?
    Yes in Malta; less so in Sicily outside tourist spots.
  3. Better beaches?
    Sicily for sand; Malta for diving (Map of Beaches in Malta).
  4. Visit both?
    Yes, ferries connect Valletta to Pozzallo in 1 hour 45 minutes.
  5. More budget-friendly?
    Malta often feels cheaper (Budget Travel to Malta).

Conclusion

Malta and Sicily are Mediterranean treasures, but Malta’s compact size, English ease, and ancient wonders—like the Ġgantija Temples—make it our slight favorite for 2025. Perfect for a quick, unforgettable trip, dive into Malta’s charm at Manic Malta. Sicily’s allure shines for longer, diverse escapes, but Malta’s got the edge this year!