A Practical Guide to Six Thinking Hats | Maltese Mental Models
Posted inMaltese Mental Models

A Practical Guide to Six Thinking Hats | Maltese Mental Models


Malta Short Let: Cozy Stay in Gzira
Sliema Area
Modern Designer Finished
2 Bedrooms + Games Room.
First floor with Maltese Balcony
Large back Terrace with swinging sofa
Fully Airconditioned + Full Kitchen
3 TVs, including 65” with backlight.
 Apartment Image
Book Now:
Google Travel | Direct (Cheapest) | Booking.com | Airbnb

🎩 A Practical Guide to Six Thinking Hats

Part of the Maltese Mental Models series on Edward de Bono’s thinking tools

⚠️ Disclaimer: This article is an independent educational analysis of the Six Thinking Hats® methodology. Our purpose is to provide commentary and a practical guide for applying these concepts. Six Thinking Hats® is a registered trademark and the intellectual property of the de Bono Group. This content is not created, endorsed by, or affiliated with the official de Bono organization. For official training and certification, please visit the de Bono Thinking Systems website.

🤔 The Common Meeting Problem

Consider a typical meeting about launching a new product. One person attacks the idea (“Too expensive!”). Another defends it emotionally (“But customers love it!”). A third person presents large amounts of data, while someone else brings up irrelevant success stories. After two hours, nothing is decided, participants are frustrated, and the real issues remain unexplored.

This is an example of what Dr. Edward de Bono, the renowned Maltese thinker, termed “spaghetti thinking”—a phrase he coined to describe everyone pulling in different directions simultaneously.

🔑 Core Principle: De Bono’s key insight was that the problem isn’t the people, but the cognitive overload of trying to do everything at once. Our brains struggle to be creative, logical, critical, and emotional all at the same time.

His solution, developed in 1985, was a simple yet profound framework: Six Thinking Hats. It provides a language for focusing and coordinating group thinking, transforming adversarial debate into collaborative exploration.

🤝 The Power of Parallel Thinking

The central concept behind Six Hats is “parallel thinking.” Instead of participants arguing against each other, they explore a subject together, side-by-side.

Adversarial vs. Parallel Thinking
Traditional (Adversarial) Thinking Six Hats (Parallel) Thinking
Participants defend their own viewpoint. All participants look in the same direction at the same time.
Thinking is an unsorted mix of ego, emotion, and logic. Thinking is separated into distinct, focused modes (the hats).
The goal is to win the argument. The goal is to fully explore the subject.

⚡ Pro Tip: By design, parallel thinking minimizes ego-driven conflict, creating a collaborative environment where ideas can flourish.

🎨 The Six Hats Explained

In this framework, each hat represents a distinct mode of thinking. When a hat is “in use,” all participants must adopt that specific thinking style.

The Six Thinking Hats Overview
Hat Core Function Key Question
⚪ White Hat Analyzing objective data and information What information do we have? What do we need?
🔴 Red Hat Expressing intuition, hunches, and feelings How do we feel about this?
🟡 Yellow Hat Exploring benefits with logical reasoning What are the positives? Why might this work?
⚫ Black Hat Applying caution and critical judgment What could go wrong? What are the dangers?
🟢 Green Hat Generating creative ideas and alternatives What else is possible? Are there other ways?
🔵 Blue Hat Managing the thinking process itself How should we think? What is our agenda?

⚪ White Hat: Objective Facts

When wearing the White Hat, you think like a neutral journalist or a data analyst. The focus is exclusively on facts, free from interpretation or argument.

Core Principle: This mode centers on neutral, objective information, helping the group establish a shared understanding of known facts and identify knowledge gaps. It’s often enhanced by systematically using the CAF (Consider All Factors) tool.

🔴 Red Hat: Emotions and Intuition

The Red Hat is like a heart-to-heart conversation. It’s a safe space to express feelings and gut instincts without needing to justify them.

Core Principle: This mode legitimizes the sharing of feelings and hunches without justification, ensuring emotional responses are heard. To gather a full spectrum of feelings, it pairs powerfully with OPV (Other People’s Views).

🟡 Yellow Hat: Logical Benefits

With the Yellow Hat, you’re an optimistic strategist, seeking the bright side. Every benefit must be backed by logical reasoning.

Core Principle: This mode encourages a deliberate search for benefits and value, always supported by logical reasoning. It focuses on the ‘Plus’ side of a PMI and explores positive long-term outcomes with C&S.

⚫ Black Hat: Caution and Critical Thinking

The Black Hat is your inner risk manager, not a pessimist. It’s about spotting potential pitfalls to protect the group’s success.

Core Principle: This mode serves to protect the group from mistakes by identifying potential risks and flaws. It’s the hat for the ‘Minus’ in a PMI and for considering negative C&S (Consequences and Sequels).

🟢 Green Hat: Creativity and Growth

Wearing the Green Hat, you’re a bold inventor, free to dream up wild ideas. This is where innovation thrives without judgment.

Core Principle: This mode is dedicated to brainstorming new possibilities, powered by Lateral Thinking. It’s where you use tools like APC (Alternatives, Possibilities, Choices) and Provocative Operation (PO).

🔵 Blue Hat: Process Management

The Blue Hat is the conductor of the thinking orchestra. It keeps the group focused, on time, and moving toward clear outcomes.

Core Principle: This “meta-thinking” mode focuses on managing the process. The Blue Hat defines the AGO for the session and uses the overarching DATT Framework to decide which hat to use next.

🔗 Connecting the Hats to the Broader Toolkit

The Six Thinking Hats are a powerful system on their own, but they become even more effective when you see them as a way to organize the other thinking tools in this series. Each hat provides a perfect context for applying specific tools.

Synergy: Six Hats and Other Mental Models
Hat in Use Supercharge it with… How They Work Together
🔵 Blue Hat AGO, FIP, DATT The Blue Hat sets the meeting’s AGO, determines the FIP, and uses the DATT framework to structure the entire thinking sequence.
⚪ White Hat CAF (Consider All Factors) While under the White Hat, you can run a CAF to ensure you have gathered all necessary facts and identified all information gaps systematically.
🟢 Green Hat APC, PO, Lateral Thinking The Green Hat is the home for creativity. You use APC to generate options and PO (a key part of Lateral Thinking) to break patterns and find breakthroughs.
🟡/⚫ Yellow & Black Hats PMI, C&S The Yellow (Plus) and Black (Minus) Hats are essentially a structured, deep-dive version of a PMI. You can also use C&S under both hats to evaluate long-term positive and negative outcomes.
🔴 Red Hat OPV (Other People’s Views) To get a full emotional picture, the Red Hat shouldn’t just be your own feelings. Use OPV to actively consider the Red Hat perspectives of customers, competitors, and colleagues.

🧠 The Rationale and Reported Benefits

The Six Hats method aligns with how the brain functions. Different thinking modes activate competing neural networks. Focusing on one mode at a time enhances effectiveness.

Core Principle: By separating distinct cognitive tasks, the method aims to prevent “cognitive conflict,” allowing the brain to perform each function more effectively.

Commonly Reported Benefits

  • ✅ Increased Meeting Efficiency: Eliminates circular arguments, making meetings shorter and more productive.
  • ✅ Reduced Conflict: Depersonalizes criticism by focusing on ideas, not people.
  • ✅ Improved Decision Quality: Considers all angles—facts, emotions, pros, cons, and creativity—for robust decisions.
  • ✅ Enhanced Creativity: Green Hat creates a safe space for innovative ideas without immediate judgment.

📋 Strategic Sequences

The order of hats is a strategic choice made by the Blue Hat facilitator. Different sequences suit different tasks.

Common Hat Sequences for Different Situations
Situation Example Sequence Rationale
Generating New Ideas 🔵 Blue → ⚪ White → 🟢 Green → 🟡 Yellow → ⚫ Black → 🔴 Red → 🔵 Blue Builds on creativity and benefits before criticism.
Evaluating a Proposal 🔵 Blue → ⚪ White → 🟡 Yellow → ⚫ Black → 🔴 Red → 🔵 Blue Balances pros, cons, and feelings about an option.
Improving a Process 🔵 Blue → ⚪ White → ⚫ Black → 🟢 Green → 🔵 Blue Defines facts and problems before solutions.

💡 Remember: A skilled Blue Hat facilitator tailors sequences to the meeting’s goals for maximum impact.

🏭 Applying the Method: Maltese Scenarios

Imagine applying Six Hats to real-world challenges in Malta’s dynamic environment.

Illustrative Examples of Six Hats in Use
Scenario Challenge How Six Hats Could Help
Tourism Authority Managing overtourism Map facts (⚪ White), concerns (🔴 Red/⚫ Black), and creative solutions like off-season campaigns (🟢 Green).
Hospital Administration Reducing ER waiting times Analyze processes (⚪ White/⚫ Black), brainstorm workflows (🟢 Green), gauge staff feelings (🔴 Red).
Local Council Resolving parking disputes Separate feelings (🔴 Red) from data (⚪ White) and explore solutions (🟢 Green).

Case: The Gozo Tunnel Debate

Applying Six Hats to the proposed Gozo-Malta tunnel:

  • ⚪ White Hat: Agree on facts: ferry data, cost estimates, timelines, missing data (e.g., environmental studies).
  • 🔴 Red Hat: Share emotions: excitement for convenience, fear of losing Gozo’s character, cost anxiety.
  • 🟡 Yellow Hat: Brainstorm benefits: 24/7 connectivity, economic growth, emergency access.
  • ⚫ Black Hat: List risks: environmental damage, debt, construction disruption.
  • 🟢 Green Hat: Explore creative ideas: rail-only tunnel, enhanced ferry, phased approach.
  • 🔵 Blue Hat: Summarize complexities, list next steps (e.g., commission studies).

🛠️ Implementation and Facilitation

The success of a Six Hats session depends on the Blue Hat facilitator.

Core Principle: The facilitator’s role is to ensure discipline by keeping the group on one hat at a time while maintaining strict neutrality on the content.

  1. Prepare: Define meeting focus and hat sequence.
  2. Protect: Redirect stray thinking to the current hat.
  3. Manage Time: Keep to time limits for momentum.
  4. Stay Neutral: Focus on process, not content.

⚡ Pro Tip: Use phrases like “That’s a great point, let’s hold it for the Yellow Hat. For now, let’s all stay on our Black Hats” to guide the group.

📚 Practice Exercises

Using Six Hats becomes natural with practice.

Solo Practice

Daily Decision Practice: Spend 60 seconds per hat on a decision (e.g., weekend plans). Note which hats feel natural.

Team Practice

Simple Team Activities
Activity Duration Purpose
Speed Hats 15-20 min Practice rapid hat-switching on a fun topic (e.g., team outing).
Silent Six Hats 30-45 min Use sticky notes to include introverts and prevent dominance.

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is Six Hats only for business meetings?
A: No, it’s versatile for education, family decisions, or personal reflection.
Q: What if someone resists?
A: Acknowledge skepticism, ask for a short trial. Clarity often wins them over.
Q: Biggest beginner mistake?
A: Weak Blue Hat facilitation, allowing disorganized debate.

🧠 Conclusion: Mastering Your Thinking

The Six Thinking Hats framework is more than just a meeting tool; it’s a discipline for clearer, more comprehensive, and more collaborative thinking. By separating modes of thought, it allows individuals and teams to move beyond ego-driven debate and fully explore any subject. As you’ve seen, it’s also the perfect framework for organizing the entire suite of de Bono’s attention-directing tools. Whether you’re solving a complex business problem, planning a family vacation, or simply organizing your own thoughts, practicing the Six Hats will lead to better processes and superior outcomes. Start with one hat, practice with a small team, and watch how it transforms confusion into clarity.

Navigation: ← Previous: PO | Series Start | Next: DATT Framework →

Part of the Maltese Mental Models series • Teaching Edward de Bono’s thinking tools for the AI age